I sit opposite a female client in my consulting room. I hear
her say: ‘All men are evil. What hope do women have? How about our daughters?’.
I challenge my client with the obvious: ‘I’m a man’. To my surprise, her facial
expression was one of shock. It was difficult for her to reconcile her notion
of ‘all men are evil’ and knowing me, a man who had been holding her emotional
space and helped her heal over the last six months. Thoughts like ‘all men are
evil’ is what we, psychotherapists, call ‘global thinking’.
I can’t blame her. Global thinking is prevalent in today’s
society, especially through social media, as is ‘black and white thinking’:
some things are good, some things are bad. There is no room for grey areas.
Yet, my clinical experience, and life, has taught me that reality is hardly
black or white, and is mainly composed of various shades of grey. During my
career as a psychosexual and relationship therapist, I have noticed that global
thinking and black and white thinking encourage the movement of shaming male
sexuality and, at the same time, promoting the fear of male sexuality: ‘men who
watch porn are bad’. ‘men are cheaters’. ‘men sexually offend’.
Douglas Murray calls this movement a ‘sexual
counter-revolution’ in his article in The Spectator published on the 4th
November 2017. In his opinion, the new ‘feminism’ is ‘producing manifestos for
torturing men’ to the extent that ‘no sex at all’ will become the new
appropriate behaviour. I fear that Murray is right, given what I hear in my
consulting room, more and more, and especially since the Weinstein scandal and
the subsequent #MeToo movement.
I am not denying the struggles of women in a patriarchal
world: women have to endure men putting them down and sexually objectifying
them, every day. It is not ok for women to live like this. The #MeToo movement
has created empowerment for some women to speak out, which is positive. But it
is equally important to remember that not all men are sexual offenders or
predators. Most men are loving, caring and kind. Perhaps some are awkward and
ignorant and say the wrong things at the wrong time: it is clumsy, but it is
not a criminal offence.
Soon after #MeToo, another movement took off: #ImperfectMen,
to encourage men to say that they are imperfect. What good would it do to
anybody? With #ImperfectMen, it is a way to silence men again, and to put them
all in the box of ‘Not Good Enough’. I prefer #WhatIHaveLearnt. This seems more
appropriate to me because it can create a discussion without shame. Sadly, that
one didn’t take off.
And, by the way, nobody is perfect.
What appeared on social media besides #MeToo and
#ImperfectMen is multiple articles and blogs with headlines like: ‘The 5 top
things to never say to a woman’. ‘The 10 things you must do to be a better
man’. ‘The 5 signs to find out if your boyfriend is a cheater’, etc. Rather
than ordering men to act exactly in this way or that way so that they can be a ‘good
man’ or a ‘better man’, why not have an ongoing conversation between a man and
a woman: because women, too, are not all the same.
Some women enjoy being told that they’re beautiful. Some
others don’t. Some women enjoy the attention from strangers. Some women don’t.
Some women have sexual fantasies of being dominant, others have sexual
fantasies of being submissive. Some women enjoy a man taking control, some
don’t. Some women welcome a flirty touch on the shoulder or the knee, some
don’t. Some women enjoy watching porn, some don’t. Some women, too, exploit
men’s vulnerability to coerce them into sexual behaviours, most don’t.
If there is no ongoing conversation between men and women,
on an individual basis, then how can we understand what is right for one person
and what is not for another?
The conversation is simple if we stop thinking in black and
white terms, or in global thinking.
‘For me, this is ok to do this, and it is not ok when you do
that’. This is boundary setting from one individual to another.
If someone unknowingly crosses a boundary and they are told
so, this person must not minimise, argue or dismiss the assertion of
boundaries, but simply listen to the boundaries, apologise and make sure they
don’t cross the line again with this particular person. Then, they can ask for
clarification: ‘what is acceptable for you?’: this is the basis of consent.
If this dialogue happens in this way, then you have two
people who are honest and assertive and they can respect each other.
Of course, there are gross misconduct and criminal
behaviours that we all agree should never happen, like any non-consensual
activities and other illegal sexual behaviours. And we all have social norms to
respect: not intimidate or ridicule another person. I think this is pretty easy
to know what is right and what is wrong if you have been socialised by
reasonable parents. Most men know about non-consensual sexual behaviours and
what is illegal. And most men know about social norms, and they don’t breach
them. This notion that male sexuality is dangerous and that it can get out of
control quickly is pure fiction and fear mongering.
Of course male sex offenders exist, they are a tiny
percentage of the population. These people should have the appropriate criminal
sentence. And There are also female sex
offenders who also should have the appropriate criminal sentence.
At the same time that we demonise men, we also order them to
open up: ‘men must talk more because their mental health is poor’. Suicide
statistics are worryingly high amongst young men. But how can we give a chance
to men to open up if we’re going to shut them down as soon as they make a
genuine mistake, or be clumsy or not knowing the right word to say at the right
time?
Masculinity is beautiful. Male sexuality is as vibrant and
loving as female sexuality. Let’s embrace all of it.
Rather than demonising men, I think it is best to meet each
other with open arms, have honest ongoing conversations without making
judgements and assumptions of what we are, what we think and what we are likely
to do based on our gender.
My point in writing this blog is to offer a bit of balance
in a discource that is often too black and white. We seem to live in a world
that is polarised. But the fact is that we are men, we are women. We all do
good things and bad things. We can unknowingly offend somebody by being
insensitive and clumsy. Let us keep the judgement in the court room for the
true sex offenders. And for the rest of us, let’s allow mistakes to happen, it
is how we can learn from each other.